Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

If you do any physical work, you get sweaty, sweat means bacteria, means bad smell. Some of us don't like to stink, also don't like our beds to stink.



Hackernews told me that this is just another microbiome that needs to be brought into balance, after which the smell goes away; and that soaps and shampoos disrupt that balance.

As one who's hung out with bohemian vagabonds who didn't make a routine habit of bathing, my nose has told me otherwise.

Nice people but... humans smell funny in general.


> humans smell funny in general

A fact of life that seems pointless to try to avoid.

One person's BO is another person's aphrodisiac. Biochemistry is fun, lean into it!


What fraction of people do any substantial physical work in an average day? I reckon about 25%.


This might be more a reflection of your social bubble. I'd reckon the percentage would be more likely to be flipped. Especially if we're talking about a global population.


Men also generally stink more. Just being too warm for a few minutes means smelly armpits and crotch for loads of dudes.


Fun fact- most Koreans don't have the same sweat gland that many others have that produce the type of sweet that the stinky bacteria feed on, and thus don't stink like Americans from sweating (they do have their own smell, from what I understand, but it isn't as pungent) and thus they don't usually use deodorant/antiperspirant. It is my understanding some other Asian groups don't stink or don't stink as much, as well, due to differences in the sweat produced.


It's true of most East Asians and to a lesser degree with South Asians. Surprised I had to scroll so far to find this comment.


As someone who lived in China for years I always laugh at this myth, you clearly haven't traveled by crowded Chinese subway every day if you think Chinese don't stink (and they make up pretty much all East Asians).

And not to sound racist, but black people have (often) very different stench from the rest, that one is not Chinese (racist) myth.

But to be honest every race/nation I met stink, your nose is just blind to the people you meet most often. It's same with my apartment when I return back after longer vacation I can notice its specific (new) smell still even after years living there (especially if I won't leave windows a bit open for air exchange), but if I'm away just for a day or two I don't smell anything.


It's not a myth. The distinction here isn't general body odor, which everyone has, but a specific gene (ABCC11, the same that controls for wet or dry earwax). Those with the gene have a chemical in their underarms and groins that bacteria feeds on, producing a stinkier odor.

Also, I've ridden plenty of crowded buses and subways in China and haven't noticed as much body odor as Westerners. So our anecdotes cancel out there.


It's really not that simple. The bacteria that live on my skin don't stink like that after a lot of exercise.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: